Purpose as an Active Commitment: Lessons from William Damon

In this episode of Meaningful Work Matters, host Andrew Soren engages with William Damon, Professor of Education at Stanford University and Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution.

As one of the world's leading researchers in human development and a pioneer in the study of how people find purpose, Damon brings decades of insight to the discussion of meaningful work and purpose-driven lives.

The Triple Helix of Good Work

William Damon introduces the concept of the "triple helix" of good work, which emerged from his collaborative research with Howard Gardner and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi. This model posits that truly meaningful and impactful work requires the integration of three essential elements:

1. Excellence: A commitment to high-quality performance and continuous improvement

2. Engagement: Genuine interest and enjoyment in one's work

3. Ethics: Adherence to moral principles and values in professional conduct

Credit: https://pz.harvard.edu/resources/howard-gardner-on-good-work-for-lawyers

Damon emphasizes that all three components are necessary for work to be truly "good." He explains:

"Two out of the three weren't enough. You have to be dedicated to ethics, a commitment to excellence, and a commitment to being engaged, to enjoying what you're doing."

This holistic approach to work aligns closely with eudaimonic well-being, reflecting Aristotelian ideals of living a life of virtue, engagement, and the pursuit of one's full potential.

Purpose as an Active Commitment

Central to Damon's research is his definition of purpose, which he articulates as "an active commitment to accomplish something that is both meaningful to the self and of consequence to the world beyond the self."

This definition encompasses several crucial elements:

• Active commitment: Purpose requires sustained effort and action, not just thought or belief

• Accomplishment: There must be a goal or outcome to work towards

• Personal meaning: The pursuit must resonate with the individual's values and interests

• Beyond the self: The impact of one's efforts should extend to the broader world or community

Damon clarifies that purpose doesn't necessarily equate to altruism, stating, "You can attempt to accomplish something for the world beyond the self that doesn't have to do with satisfying other people."

He provides examples of scientists studying black holes or artists creating unconventional music, emphasizing that purpose can be found in various forms of contribution to knowledge, art, or society.

Challenges and Considerations

While purpose and meaningful work offer numerous benefits, Damon acknowledges potential challenges:

1. The dark side of meaningful work: Highly purposeful individuals may be at risk of exploitation or burnout, especially in fields like healthcare or non-profit work.

2. Balancing merit and equality: Damon addresses recent critiques of meritocracy, arguing that the pursuit of excellence and recognition of merit are essential for societal progress and individual fulfillment.

3. Generational shifts: While cautious about overgeneralizing cohort differences (eg Gen X vs Gen Y), Damon notes that there are changing attitudes towards work-life balance and the questioning of traditional work ethics among younger generations.

Damon's Model of Purpose Development

Drawing from his extensive research, Damon presents a model of how purpose develops over the lifespan:

1. Gradual development: Purpose often emerges slowly, with fits and starts, particularly in late adolescence and early adulthood.

2. Trial and error: Many individuals experience setbacks and periods of cynicism before finding their purpose.

3. Adaptability: As life circumstances change, individuals may need to adjust their purpose or find new sources of meaning.

4. Encore purposes: In later life stages, such as retirement, people often discover new purposes aligned with their evolving capacities and interests.

This model emphasizes the dynamic nature of purpose and the importance of remaining open to new sources of meaning throughout life.

Practical Applications and Implications

Damon offers several strategies for cultivating purpose, particularly for younger individuals:

1. Fostering gratitude: Encouraging appreciation for learning opportunities and life experiences can set the stage for purpose development.

2. Developing a sense of service: Instilling the idea that "it's not all about you" helps individuals connect their efforts to broader societal needs.

3. Balancing multiple life domains: Recognizing that purpose can be found in various areas, including work, family, civic engagement, and personal interests.

For organizations, Damon stresses the importance of authentic leadership in creating purposeful work environments:

• Clearly articulating the organization's mission and its value to society

• Aligning incentives with both organizational success and societal benefit

• Fostering a culture of integrity and ethical behavior

Conclusion

William Damon's insights offer a rich perspective on the development and cultivation of purpose throughout life. By understanding purpose as an active commitment that extends beyond the self, individuals and organizations can work towards creating more meaningful, impactful, and fulfilling work experiences.

As we navigate the complexities of modern work life, Damon's research provides valuable guidance for fostering purpose-driven lives and careers.

Resources for Further Exploration

• Damon, W. (2008). The Path to Purpose: How Young People Find Their Calling in Life

• Damon, W., Menon, J., & Bronk, K. C. (2003). The development of purpose during adolescence

• Gardner, H., Csikszentmihalyi, M., & Damon, W. (2001). Good Work: When Excellence and Ethics Meet

• Damon, W. (2021). A Round of Golf with My Father: The New Psychology of Exploring Your Past to Make Peace with Your Present

• Learn more about The Good Project here!

The Stress-Meaning Paradox: Lessons from Jess Annison

In this episode of Meaningful Work Matters, host Andrew Soren engages with Jess Annison, a UK-based positive psychology practitioner, leadership coach, and career consultant. Annison, who recently completed her master's thesis in applied positive psychology, shares her research on the intricate relationship between stress and meaningful work.

With a background in organizational change and major projects, including work on the London 2012 Olympic Games and as director of change for Europe's largest open-access university, Annison brings a wealth of practical experience to her academic pursuits. Her passion for helping people find meaning in their work, coupled with her firsthand experience of the stresses that can accompany deeply meaningful roles, led her to explore this complex topic.

The Complex Relationship Between Stress and Meaningful Work

Annison's research, published in Frontiers in Psychology, reveals a nuanced and bidirectional relationship between stress and meaningful work. Using a grounded theory approach, she identified six "complex handshakes" or ways in which stress and meaningfulness interact:

These relationships highlight the intricate nature of meaningful work, which Annison describes as having "intricate tensional knots." She emphasizes that "nothing in life is so simple that it's ever wholly great," underscoring the importance of acknowledging both the benefits and potential drawbacks of meaningful work.

Stress as a Component of Work Experience

Annison frames stress within the context of the job demands-resources theory, where stress arises when job demands exceed an individual's resources to cope. She explains that while some stress can be beneficial, chronic or acute stress can lead to various mental and physical health problems.

"Stress is when we experience challenging circumstances or demands that exceed our resources, that exceed our ability to cope.”

This definition helps listeners understand that stress is subjective and can vary based on individual perceptions and available resources.

Challenges and Considerations

The research highlights several challenges associated with meaningful work:

• Potential for overwork and burnout due to deep care for the work

• Difficulty maintaining work-life balance

• Risk of exploitation when passion is used to justify poor working conditions

• Stress potentially diminishing the perceived meaningfulness of work

Annison cautions against viewing meaningful work as a "silver bullet" for workplace well-being and emphasizes the need for awareness of these potential downsides.

Annison's Research Findings

Annison's qualitative study revealed that the relationship between stress and meaningful work is often simultaneous and complex. Participants reported experiencing both positive and negative effects concurrently. For example, meaningful work might exacerbate stress while also helping to alleviate it at the same time.

One participant aptly summarized this complexity: "A few things in life are easy and worth doing," which became the title of Annison's research paper. This phrase encapsulates the idea that worthwhile endeavors often come with challenges.

Practical Applications and Implications

To navigate the complex relationship between stress and meaningful work, Annison suggests:

For individuals:

• Reflect on personal experiences of stress and meaning in work

• Journal or discuss with a mentor to gain clarity

• Make adjustments to reduce stressors or boost coping resources

• Ensure meaningful work is part of a broader meaningful life

For organizations and leaders:

• Be mindful of unintended consequences of promoting meaningful work

• Provide space for discussions about stress and meaning

• Balance high-pressure periods with time for recovery

• Role model good practices in managing work-life boundaries

Conclusion

Jess Annison's research provides valuable insights into the nuanced relationship between stress and meaningful work.

By acknowledging both the benefits and challenges of deeply engaging work, individuals and organizations can better navigate the complexities of creating fulfilling career experiences while maintaining well-being.

Resources for Further Exploration

• Jess Annison's website: www.jess-annison.com

• Research paper: "Few Things in Life Are Easy and Worth Doing: A Grounded Theory Study of the Relationship Between Stress and Meaningful Work" (available through Frontiers in Psychology)

• Upcoming book: "Career Crafting: How to Conquer Your Mid-Career Crisis and Create Your Most Meaningful Work Life" (release date: early 2025)